kitsoki

Appearance

<!-- GENERATED FILE — DO NOT HAND-EDIT. Source of truth: tools/dev-workflow-matrix/manifest.yaml Regenerate with: make dev-workflow-matrix -->

Dev-workflow surface matrix ​

Generated from tools/dev-workflow-matrix/manifest.yaml by tools/dev-workflow-matrix/generate.py. Plan: .context/dev-workflows-surface-matrix-plan.md (§1 target matrix, WS-F F1).

Legend: ✅ works + no-LLM proven · 🟡 works but proof thin or reliability suspect · 🔴 gap · ⬜ intentionally out of scope for the surface.

Every cell carries two proof-class verdicts from schemas/completion-state.schema.json: mechanical (check_type replay; no-LLM, per-commit) and experience (check_type docs-fidelity / ux-heuristic / journey-verdict; persona-judged, budgeted — WS-G). "no standing verdict" is the honest state until the arena gate feeds this matrix.

kitsoki self-instance (.kitsoki/stories/kitsoki-dev/) ​

WorkflowTUIWebVS Codegh-agent
Onboard🟡 proof-thin🔴 gap🔴 gap⬜ out-of-scope
PRD / proposal✅ works🟡 proof-thin🟡 proof-thin🔴 gap
Decompose → implement✅ works🟡 proof-thin🟡 proof-thin🔴 gap
File a bug✅ works✅ works🟡 proof-thin✅ works
Fix a bug🟡 proof-thin🟡 proof-thin🟡 proof-thin🟡 proof-thin

Cell detail ​

  • Onboard × TUI — 🟡 proof-thin: works (init rooms flow-tested) but two divergent paths
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Onboard × Web — 🔴 gap: no web onboarding entry
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Onboard × VS Code — 🔴 gap: extension assumes an already-onboarded repo
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Onboard × gh-agent — ⬜ out-of-scope: App install ≠ repo onboarding; needs a doc'd handoff
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • PRD / proposal × TUI — ✅ works: prd story (33 flows) + design rooms (~20 flows). Canonical doc: docs/workflows/prd-and-design.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • PRD / proposal × Web — 🟡 proof-thin: drivable (PRD demo exists); typed free-text routing fixed (semanticRoutingOptions no longer forces semantic routing off) but no standing web walk of the prd chain. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/prd-and-design.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • PRD / proposal × VS Code — 🟡 proof-thin: PRD demo spec exists (vscode-prd-demo.e2e.spec.ts); v0.1.0 extension. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/prd-and-design.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • PRD / proposal × gh-agent — 🔴 gap: no label→prd/design route. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/prd-and-design.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Decompose → implement × TUI — ✅ works: deliver is the canonical chain (schema+lint absorption, budgeted refine loop, adversarial review, managed re-decompose; 11 flows) wired into dev-story (go_deliver on landing/design_done + design_to_decompose_to_impl e2e flow); fleet still thin (1 flow). Canonical doc: docs/workflows/decompose-and-implement.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Decompose → implement × Web — 🟡 proof-thin: Playwright walk of the dev-story decompose fixture via kitsoki web --flow (deliver-decompose-walk.spec.ts) — one happy-path proof; red paths unproven on web. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/decompose-and-implement.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Decompose → implement × VS Code — 🟡 proof-thin: extension e2e spec of the same walk (vscode-deliver-decompose-walk.e2e.spec.ts, real VS Code via kitsoki.flow settings) — one happy-path proof. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/decompose-and-implement.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Decompose → implement × gh-agent — 🔴 gap: no route. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/decompose-and-implement.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • File a bug × TUI — ✅ works: /bug meta modes + CLI, host tests. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/file-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • File a bug × Web — ✅ works: Report Bug modal shipped (proposal doc stale). Canonical doc: docs/workflows/file-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • File a bug × VS Code — 🟡 proof-thin: dedicated extension e2e spec (vscode-file-a-bug-walk.e2e.spec.ts, real VS Code): Meta → Report a bug → capture/review modal → describe → File bug → filed-path toast — one happy-path proof, local filing only. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/file-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • File a bug × gh-agent — ✅ works: bug-report deck auto-trigger shipped. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/file-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Fix a bug × TUI — 🟡 proof-thin: bugfix mature (80+ flows, triage mode) but silent-bounce reliability warranted its own debugging skill. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/fix-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: solved (docs-fidelity, as of 2026-07-06)
  • Fix a bug × Web — 🟡 proof-thin: drivable; staged-gate & pace issues historically. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/fix-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Fix a bug × VS Code — 🟡 proof-thin: dedicated extension e2e spec (vscode-bugfix-walk.e2e.spec.ts, real VS Code via kitsoki.flow): full bugfix pipeline idle → @exit:done — one happy-path proof; also the real-socket capture that pinned host.ide.get_diagnostics' wire shape (ide-integration.md follow-up 1). Canonical doc: docs/workflows/fix-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Fix a bug × gh-agent — 🟡 proof-thin: real dispatch of stories/bugfix landed (realDispatchPlan, per-job worktree, APP_DIR races scoped to the load span); no triage-only label route yet and end-to-end proof is thin. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/fix-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict

gears-rust thin instance (imports @kitsoki/dev-story) ​

WorkflowTUIWebVS Codegh-agent
Onboard✅ works🔴 gap🔴 gap⬜ out-of-scope
PRD / proposal🔴 gap🔴 gap🔴 gap🔴 gap
Decompose → implement🔴 gap🔴 gap🔴 gap🔴 gap
File a bug🔴 gap🔴 gap🔴 gap🔴 gap
Fix a bug🟡 proof-thin🔴 gap🔴 gap🔴 gap

Cell detail ​

  • Onboard × TUI — ✅ works: WS-A A3: a real onboard of a fresh gears-rust clone recorded through the dev-story onboard path (kitsoki session create/continue, live harness) and converted to a committed no-LLM flow+cassette (stories/dev-story/flows/onboard_gears_rust.yaml); replays green via kitsoki test flows. A2 external-ticket passthrough proven: discovery auto-binds tracker=github/ticket_repo=bsacrobatix/gears-rust from the real remote. See .context/dwf3-a3-recording-notes.md.
    • mechanical: solved (replay, as of 2026-07-06)
    • experience: solved (docs-fidelity, as of 2026-07-06)
  • Onboard × Web — 🔴 gap: not yet exercised on gears-rust; also no web onboarding entry at all
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Onboard × VS Code — 🔴 gap: not yet exercised on gears-rust; extension assumes an already-onboarded repo
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Onboard × gh-agent — ⬜ out-of-scope: App install ≠ repo onboarding; needs a doc'd handoff
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • PRD / proposal × TUI — 🔴 gap: not yet exercised on gears-rust (thin @kitsoki/dev-story instance run pending). Canonical doc: docs/workflows/prd-and-design.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • PRD / proposal × Web — 🔴 gap: not yet exercised on gears-rust. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/prd-and-design.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • PRD / proposal × VS Code — 🔴 gap: not yet exercised on gears-rust. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/prd-and-design.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • PRD / proposal × gh-agent — 🔴 gap: no label→prd/design route; nothing exercised on gears-rust. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/prd-and-design.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Decompose → implement × TUI — 🔴 gap: not yet exercised on gears-rust (WS-B exit: epic → briefs → branches with no-LLM replay). Canonical doc: docs/workflows/decompose-and-implement.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Decompose → implement × Web — 🔴 gap: not yet exercised on gears-rust. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/decompose-and-implement.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Decompose → implement × VS Code — 🔴 gap: not yet exercised on gears-rust. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/decompose-and-implement.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Decompose → implement × gh-agent — 🔴 gap: no route; nothing exercised on gears-rust. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/decompose-and-implement.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • File a bug × TUI — 🔴 gap: not yet exercised on gears-rust (needs WS-A A2 external ticket-repo passthrough). Canonical doc: docs/workflows/file-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • File a bug × Web — 🔴 gap: not yet exercised on gears-rust. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/file-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • File a bug × VS Code — 🔴 gap: not yet exercised on gears-rust. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/file-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • File a bug × gh-agent — 🔴 gap: not yet exercised on gears-rust (WS-E E3: labeled gears-rust issue → honest triage verdict). Canonical doc: docs/workflows/file-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Fix a bug × TUI — 🟡 proof-thin: a real GitHub-issue-sourced gears-rust bug (constructorfabric/gears-rust#4115) triaged read-only through the bugfix triage intent (kitsoki session new/submit, live harness) and converted to a committed no-LLM flow+cassette (stories/bugfix/flows/triage_gears_rust.yaml); replays green via kitsoki test flows. Proves the A2 external ticket-repo passthrough again on a real GitHub issue (ticket_source_mode=remote, ticket_repo=constructorfabric/gears-rust). Proof is THIN: this is the TRIAGE leg only (read-only, no worktree) — no end-to-end fix/PR has been exercised on gears-rust; the maker/implementer/reviewer/validator rooms remain untouched. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/fix-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: solved (replay, as of 2026-07-06)
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Fix a bug × Web — 🔴 gap: not yet exercised on gears-rust. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/fix-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Fix a bug × VS Code — 🔴 gap: not yet exercised on gears-rust. Canonical doc: docs/workflows/fix-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict
  • Fix a bug × gh-agent — 🔴 gap: real dispatch exists but nothing exercised on gears-rust (WS-E exit: real triage/fix on a gears-rust issue). Canonical doc: docs/workflows/fix-a-bug.md
    • mechanical: no standing verdict
    • experience: no standing verdict